I'm 5'9" and 135 lbs. I ordered the small to get the "sweater" fit, and that's what I got - though the size is a little shorter than I'd prefer (I'm rather short waisted so this is rarely a problem for me). The finer down does come out and I have flecks all over my sweaters and car seat. It's not enough to wear the jacket any less, but it is a bit annoying. It is amazingly light, compact and warm, and wears well under additional layers as others have mentioned. It is also much more wind resistant than I expected.

I love this "sweater". It is light weight, warm and so comfy. I received many compliments on how it looks on and surprise when they see how light and warm it is.

Before I purchased this product I had read that it might have some problems with the down coming out, and I've been looking out for it since. As with all down products, some little bits of down will eventually come out, especially with very fine down like the ones in this jacket. It did not really come out in an alarming way though, and the jacket is really quite warm. People who touched it gasped in surprise at its lightness and softness. And I love the lava color!

I obviously haven't had this very long because it's a new product, but have taken it on every hike since I got it, because it really does pack down neatly and zips into its own pocket, and it's really lightweight. It puffs right back up and is super warm. It's not a big puffy, because it's a "sweater" meant to pack away, and that's exactly what I wanted---something to carry just in case or if a stopping place is a bit chilly. It also fits under the Igniter jacket without compressing either jacket's insulation. I chose it because I knew Eddie Bauer fits tend to be more shapped for women than some brands. I have a full range of motion with my arms, but don't have a bunch of spare garment around the middle. I am 5' 8" with a frame to match, and got the large. It fits as a mid-layer. The lava color is a bright red orange, and I like it.

I'm 5'3.5" and 130 pounds. I ordered a petite medium and I am very happy with the fit. The sleeves rest comfortably at my wrists but could be pulled down to my knuckles. The back of the top goes just short of half way down my butt with the front sitting where a low-rise style jean would. The jacket/sweater is clearly cut with the women's form in mind as I have enough room in the chest and a comfortably flattering waist. With the top on less than a minute I immediately felt its warming properties at work. Weighing the jacket for myself it came in at an almost not there 9 ounces! Out of curiosity I put my Marmot Precip (size s/p) jacket on over the sweater to see if this could be a complete, weatherproof system without causing the down to lose is heat-trapping loft. It worked great! I have not field tested this seemingly wonderful new piece of gear but by all accounts I am extremely pleased with my purchase.